图片展示
图片展示
图片展示

Design Patent Invalidated by Prior Trademark

Author:Stephen Yang Click: Time:2022-08-19 13:00:00


Renault’s Chinese design patent No. ZL202130363449.5 for their MOBILIZE vehicles was invalidated by CNIPA on August 2, 2022 on the basis of conflicting with other’s prior trademark right.


Chinese auto maker “Human Horizon” requested CNIPA to invalidate this design patent. Human Horizon owns a Chinese car brand “HiPhi” and owns a Chinese trademark No.33004007 in class 12 with approved goods including vehicles. This trademark, being used on HiPhi cars, was registered on December 7, 2019 and remains valid until December 6, 2029.

 

Renault’s design application No. 202130363449.5 was filed on June 11, 2021. As shown in the drawings of this design patent, the logo    is used in the center of each wheel and on the rear side of the trunk.

 

CNIPA is of the opinion that in Renault’s logo    and Human Horizon’s trademark both give the relevant public the overall impression of a line segment being in the center and separating a bracket. In addition, the angle of the pattern varies depending on the viewing angle. Therefore, CNIPA found that    is similar to  and the use of a pattern similar to a registered trademark on goods of same class constitute conflict of prior trademark right. According to Article 23.3 of China Patent Law, any design for which a patent right is granted must not conflict with the lawful rights acquired by any other person before the filing date. Therefore, CNIPA declared Renault’s Chinese design patent ZL202130363449.5 invalid.

 

  is a logo Renault uses for its MOBILIZE vehicles. Renault and Human Horizon had trademark disputes over the similarity between    and  in Germany in 2021. A German court decided that    and  are not similar. However, Renault’s Chinese trademark application for    has been rejected by CNIPA. In hindsight, it would have been prudent for Renault to avoid including the logo    in the design drawings, as it is well aware of the Human Horizon’s position in enforcing its own trademark .

 

Generally speaking, applicants for design rights and their attorneys need to evaluate whether it is a good practice to include any trademark in the drawings of a design application. Unless the use of a trademark has significant contribution to the overall visual effect of the design instead of merely serving the function of a trademark, it is best not to include any trademark in the drawings of a design application, to avoid potential risks of trademark disputes.


Design Patent Invalidated by Prior Trademark
Renault’s Chinese design patent No. ZL202130363449.5 for their MOBILIZE vehicles
Long by picture save/share

Contact Us

Adress:1506 Satellite Building, 63 Zhichun Road Haidian District, Beijing, 100190, China 
Postcode:100190
Tel: 86-10-62966619
Fax: 86-10-62983448
Website: www.ipmarch.cn
Email:IP March

Contact Us

Adress:1506 Satellite Building, 63 Zhichun Road Haidian District, Beijing, 100190, China  
Postcode:100190
Tel: 86-10-62966619
Fax: 86-10-62983448
Website:www.ipmarch.cn
Email:info@ipmarch.cn


添加微信好友,详细了解产品
使用企业微信
“扫一扫”加入群聊
复制成功
添加微信好友,详细了解产品
我知道了